Man Fined $60k for Using Zone Transfers, Whois
According to an article published by The Register on January 17, a gentleman called David Ritz was fined $60,000 for doing DNS lookups. Apparently, this ruling by District Court, County of Cass, State of North Dakota was largely based on a finding that David had been using zone transfers and Whois service to hack the two authoritative DNS servers of a certain specialist web hosting and Internet services firm. As I really couldn’t believe what I was reading – and based on the comments posted at The Register I wasn’t alone – I decided to have an actual look at the ruling itself. After all, if using zone transfers was a crime, most network and system admins would be looking to do some serious jailtime.
To read the ruling yourself, please click here.
Now, while the merits of this case are certainly debatable, I’ll leave that to others. What I’d like to point out, though, is that the plaintiff in this case – a specialist web hosting and Internet services firm – was running two public, authoritative DNS servers containing confidential DNS data that they did not want to disclose to the public. Yet practically anyone who cared to initiate zone transfers was allowed to do that. In my books, it’s like leaving your door open – not unlocked but wide open – and then being upset about the fact that someone came in. If you asked me, the plaintiff had it coming.
But what strikes me the most is this: although leaving one’s door open for anyone to come in sounds a little gullible to say the least, there are literally millions of public DNS servers out there that have been configured insecurely and are open for anyone to access. Yes, millions. Yet if you asked the system administrators responsible for these DNS servers whether or not their servers were securely managed and configured, they would most likely say ‘yes’ and then share a clever detail or two of the finesses of managing a DNS server. Doesn’t it sound like there’s a bit of a discrepancy at play here?
The reason for the discrepancy is simple enough, though: plain vanilla BIND servers that make up some 80%+ of all public DNS servers come with default configurations that are not secure. And this, my dear readers, is exactly why we developed Nixu Secure Name Server (SNS): to protect your DNS servers by making the related installation, configuration and management processes a walk in the park.